This story is part of our series celebrating America’s 250th anniversary. Find more captivating stories from the VA History Office at America 250.
As another Thanksgiving is upon us, thoughts turn towards the traditions that surround the holiday, many of them involving food. Amid shopping, chopping, baking and barking, there may be some among us who stand in the middle of the kitchen wondering how those before us got it all done.
At the National VA History Center Archives, staff members (tired of their own frantic recipe Googling) went looking to see what past Thanksgivings looked like and were rewarded with positive results.
From a note in the Cincinnati Enquirer dated 26 November 1897, we know that several thousand pies, 500 quarts of cranberry sauce, and 25 bushels of sweet potato were on the menu. Also noted was the presence of approximately 5,000 Veterans. (The Archives team now looks upon their own more modest families, and the dishes that will need washed, a little more favorably.)
Forty years later, in 1931, very little changed, other than the oyster dressing being changed out for sage.
Interestingly, on the day this menu was used, Thanksgiving was not a legal holiday. That didn’t happen until 1941, in which the fourth Thursday of November was declared as Thanksgiving Day.
Moving forward almost 40 more years, the 1970 menu has a little more color and vibrancy, but items served changed little, with the possible exception of, again, the dressing. Here, the menu shows southern dressing. Since some team members were back to Googling recipes, it seems that Southern dressing is made with liberal amounts of sage and oysters are optional. So, really, nothing has changed.
From everyone at the VA History Office, we wish you and your family a warm, safe holiday.
Sources
Share this story
Related Stories
Featured Stories
The 3rd Massachusetts Cavalry Monument in the Year of the Fire Horse
In the southwest quadrant of Winchester National Cemetery, located in the town of the same name in Virginia, sits an impressive monument to the 3rd Massachusetts Cavalry that pays tribute to both man and beast. The monument is adorned with a bas-relief of a horse’s head, wild-eyed and straining at its bridle. As February 2026 marked the start of the Lunar New Year and the Year of the Horse, this is an opportune time to explore the history of the regiment and its monument. According to Chinese astrology, the horse is hard-working, agreeable, and courageous, although it also chafes at being controlled by others, something the men of the 3rd Massachusetts Cavalry experienced firsthand. Stated one soldier, “The taming of wild animals was something I did not dream of when I enlisted in '62.”
Featured Stories
The Declaration of Independence and the First Veterans Benefits
The Declaration of Independence and the first Revolutionary War benefits act were both approved 250 years ago during the tumultuous summer of 1776. These events were linked. Delegates to the Second Continental Congress waited until they had settled the question of independence before deciding how to treat the citizen-soldiers wounded in service to the Nation.
Featured Stories
Forgotten Patriot: Colonel Thomas Hunt, U.S. Army
As America commemorates its 250th anniversary, stories of patriotism and heroism long forgotten will be revived and retold. Colonel Thomas Hunt, a Veteran of the Revolutionary and Indian Wars interred at Jefferson Barracks National Cemetery was one of those heroes. Hunt’s plain marble headstone may suggest a lack of noteworthiness, but at one point in the early history of our Nation, soldiers sang the praises of “the good, the brave and generous Hunt.”
