Substitution in the Civil War exhibit image.

From Border States to National Cemeteries

When the U.S. had to increase enlistments to handle the burden of manpower demands for the battlefield, a draft was legislated in 1863. A provision was written in that gave a drafted person the choice to pay someone who was willing to serve in their place. This was called substitution. 

In the exhibit above, follow the path that four Black Americans from the Border States took in the Civil War. Through examination of enlistment records and battle reports, the story of Privates Jacob Saunders, James Murray, Thomas Jones and Harrison Lockwood illustrates the controversial nature of the substitution provision. Regardless of how they enlisted, each man served their country and were buried in National Cemeteries.

By Jacob Klinger

National Cemetery Administration history intern and West Virginia University doctoral student

Share this story

Published on Nov. 11, 2021

Estimated reading time is 0.7 min.

Related Stories

  • Read To Bring Light to Where There is Darkness: VA Chaplains and Religious Artifacts from the National VA History Center

    Exhibits

    To Bring Light to Where There is Darkness: VA Chaplains and Religious Artifacts from the National VA History Center

    For more than 150 years, VA chaplains have served Veterans with care and compassion, proving that they are indelible to the fabric of Veterans' health. Objects in this exhibit, housed in the National VA History Center (NVAHC), help tell the story of chaplaincy’s enduring presence and its profound impact on Veteran care.

  • Read VA Research at 100: A Century of Medical Advancements

    Exhibits

    VA Research at 100: A Century of Medical Advancements

    In 1925, 100 years ago, the Veterans Bureau initiated the first hospital-based medical research studies to address Veteran-specific issues like mental health, tuberculosis, cancer and toxic exposure. The program has since made significant medical breakthroughs and innovations, impacting the world.

  • Read Adaptive Exhilaration: Equipment from the National Disabled Veterans Winter Sports Clinic

    Exhibits

    Adaptive Exhilaration: Equipment from the National Disabled Veterans Winter Sports Clinic

    In 2024, the National Disabled Veterans Winter Sports Clinic, hosted by the Grand Junction VA Medical Center and co-presented with Disabled American Veterans, will donate adaptive ski equipment from the early years of the event to the National VA History Center in Dayton, Ohio. The clinic started i​n 1986 when VA established it and then held the the inaugural event at Powderhorn the following year. The clinic welcomed approximately 90 Veterans from 27 states, bolstered by a volunteer staff of about 20. Despite skepticism from many health professionals of the era, the clinic underscored the importance of physical activity for persons of all abilities.​

    This exhibit includes multiple items that were used at the early clinics, which are finding a new home at the National VA History Center.