Newspaper clipping from 1897 describing Thanksgiving for Veterans at Dayton National Home for Volunteer Soldiers. (Cincinnati Enquirer, newspapers.com)
Newspaper clipping from 1897 describing Thanksgiving for Veterans at Dayton National Home for Volunteer Soldiers. (Cincinnati Enquirer, newspapers.com)

As another Thanksgiving is upon us, thoughts turn towards the traditions that surround the holiday, many of them involving food. Amid shopping, chopping, baking and barking, there may be some among us who stand in the middle of the kitchen wondering how those before us got it all done.

At the National VA History Center Archives, staff members (tired of their own frantic recipe Googling) went looking to see what past Thanksgivings looked like and were rewarded with positive results.

From a note in the Cincinnati Enquirer dated 26 November 1897, we know that several thousand pies, 500 quarts of cranberry sauce, and 25 bushels of sweet potato were on the menu. Also noted was the presence of approximately 5,000 Veterans. (The Archives team now looks upon their own more modest families, and the dishes that will need washed, a little more favorably.)

Forty years later, in 1931, very little changed, other than the oyster dressing being changed out for sage.

Menu from a 1930 Thanksgiving meal at Dayton. (NVAHC)
Menu from a 1930 Thanksgiving meal at Dayton. (NVAHC)
Menu from a 1930 Thanksgiving meal at Dayton. (NVAHC)
Menu from a 1930 Thanksgiving meal at Dayton. (NVAHC)

Interestingly, on the day this menu was used, Thanksgiving was not a legal holiday. That didn’t happen until 1941, in which the fourth Thursday of November was declared as Thanksgiving Day.

Moving forward almost 40 more years, the 1970 menu has a little more color and vibrancy, but items served changed little, with the possible exception of, again, the dressing. Here, the menu shows southern dressing. Since some team members were back to Googling recipes, it seems that Southern dressing is made with liberal amounts of sage and oysters are optional. So, really, nothing has changed.

Menu from a 1970 Thanksgiving meal at Dayton. Image of a tree on a orange tinted landscape with pumpkins, brown fence and opaque yellow skyline. (NVAHC)
Menu from a 1970 Thanksgiving meal at Dayton. (NVAHC)
Menu from a 1970 Thanksgiving meal at Dayton. (NVAHC)
Menu from a 1970 Thanksgiving meal at Dayton. (NVAHC)

From everyone at the VA History Office, we wish you and your family a warm, safe holiday.

Sources

National VA History Center archives

By Robyn Rodgers

Senior Archivist, VA History Office and the National VA History Center

Share this story

Published on Nov. 23, 2021

Estimated reading time is 1.9 min.

Related Stories

  • Read Muskogee VA: A Hundred Years of Native American Veteran Care

    Featured Stories

    Muskogee VA: A Hundred Years of Native American Veteran Care

    Native Americans have served the United States with honor, loyalty, and bravery since the Revolutionary War. Despite facing discrimination, many Native American Veterans volunteered for service throughout the centuries, making significant contributions on the battlefield. Some saw it as fighting not only to protect the United States, but also their ancestral land. For their sacrifice, the VA hospital in Muskogee has led the charge in providing exceptional care for Native American Veterans for 100 years.

  • Read Celebrating Women Veterans, Past and Present: Dr. Ivy Brooks

    Featured Stories

    Celebrating Women Veterans, Past and Present: Dr. Ivy Brooks

    As a historian, connecting the present day with past events is a process fundamental to the profession. Researchers typically rely on information contained in archives and databases, but sometimes the most relevant details are provided by people. This was the case as a newly arrived historian at the Tuskegee VA Hospital attempted to ascertain details surrounding the life and career of Dr. Ivy Brooks, former director of radiology.

  • Read 1870 Annual Report for the National Home for Disabled Volunteer Soldiers

    Featured Stories

    1870 Annual Report for the National Home for Disabled Volunteer Soldiers

    Have you ever wondered where do historians, curators and archivists find all the information that goes into museum exhibits, books, and documentaries? One place is government reports. The National VA History Center preserves the history of the National Home for Disabled Volunteer Soldiers as a predecessor of the modern VA. We do a lot of research related to objects from the Home and we write about what life was like for those who lived and worked there. The Annual Reports that were provided to congress are a great place to look for this information. These reports provide a great deal of information, and you don’t have to travel to an archive, can do it from your computer. See the link at the bottom to access the reports.