VA’s national cemetery system is far more expansive in terms of interments and properties than the three other federal agencies with similar responsibilities—Department of Army (DA), American Battle Monuments Commission (ABMC), and National Park Service (NPS). National shrines in the VA system are kept at the highest standards and visited by the public and distinguished visitors regularly. Yet, surprisingly, over the 160 years that many VA cemeteries have existed, U.S. presidents have rarely delivered speeches on these hallowed grounds. There a few documented instances in the late nineteenth century and a storm canceled Barack Obama’s planned 2010 Memorial Day speech at Abraham Lincoln National Cemetery in Illinois. And while VA cemeteries display a plaque bearing the text of Lincoln’s Gettysburg Address, that famous piece of presidential oratory was delivered in what is now an NPS national cemetery. Otherwise, U.S. presidents have favored DA’s Arlington National Cemetery as a backdrop for Memorial and Veterans Day speeches and other special observances.
The scarcity of presidential appearances at VA cemeteries makes President William J. Clinton’s speech at the National Memorial Cemetery of the Pacific, more popularly known as the Punchbowl, on September 2, 1995, particularly noteworthy. Clinton visited the Punchbowl on V-J or Victory over Japan Day as part of a three-day commemoration celebrating the fiftieth anniversary of the end of World War II. Born in 1946, Clinton himself made history in 1992 when he became the first member of the post-WWII generation to be elected president. In its own way, the event at the Punchbowl marked the changing of an era.
Clinton’s 17-minute remarks were the last of an hour-long ceremony held on the steps of the ABMC’s Honolulu Memorial within the cemetery, described by VA Secretary Jesse Brown as a “vast and beautiful place of rest, like a cradle dropped from heaven [that] gently holds those who paid the ultimate sacrifice.” A crowd of some 6,500 attended , many of them WWII Veterans. They began gathering among the 33,000 graves decorated with American flags as early as 5 a.m. in a drizzling rain. In his address, Clinton focused on the sacrifices of the WWII generation and progress they made possible for American society:
Toward the end of the speech, President Clinton requested that all WWII Veterans in the audience stand or wave a hand to be recognized. The camera panned across the crowd as hundreds rose to their feet, many wearing the medals they had earned for their service, and the drumbeat of applause sounded in the air. One of the Veterans so honored, Navy Captain Jim Daniels III, who figured prominently in Clinton’s speech, died nine years later and was laid to rest in that very cemetery, in Section CT4-Q, Row 100, Site 153.
View the full ceremony on C-SPAN. President Clinton’s remarks begin at 25:06 and conclude at 41:30.
Note: The WWII generation is rapidly disappearing. The number of Veterans who served in the war has fallen from around one million in 2015 to 240,000 in 2022.
By Richard Hulver, Ph.D.
Historian, National Cemetery Administration
Share this story
Related Stories
History of VA in 100 Objects
Object 86: The Roll of Honor
“The following pages are devoted to the memory of those heroes who have given up their lives upon the altar of their country, in defense of the American Union.”
So opened the preface to the first volume of the Roll of Honor, a compendium of over 300,000 Federal soldiers who died during the Civil War and were interred in national and other cemeteries. The genesis of this 27-volume collection published between 1865 and 1871 can be traced to Quartermaster General Montgomery C. Meigs and the department he oversaw for a remarkable 21 years from 1861 to 1882.
History of VA in 100 Objects
Object 85: Congressman Claypool’s “$1 Per Day Pension” Ribbon
Founded in 1866 as fraternal organization for Union Veterans, the Grand Army of the Republic (GAR) embraced a new mission in the 1880s: political activism. The GAR formed a pension committee in 1881 for the express purpose of lobbying Congress for more generous pension benefits.
An artifact from the political wrangling over pensions is now part of the permanent collection of the National VA History Center in Dayton, Ohio. The item is a small pension ribbon displaying the message: “I endorse the $1 per day pension as recommended by the Departments of Ohio and Indiana G.A.R.” The button attached to the ribbon features two American flags and the phrase “saved by the boys of ’61-65.” The back of the ribbon bears the signature of Horatio C. Claypool, a Democratic judge who ran for the seat in Ohio’s eleventh Congressional district in the 1910 mid-term elections.
History of VA in 100 Objects
Object 84: Gettysburg Address Tablet
President Abraham Lincoln is one of the most revered figures in American history. Rankings of U.S. presidents routinely place him at or near the top of the list. Lincoln is also held in high esteem at VA. His stirring call during his second inaugural address in 1865 to “care for him who shall have borne the battle and for his widow and his orphan” embodies the nation’s promise to all who wear the uniform, a promise VA and its predecessor administrations have kept ever since the Civil War.
Ever since Lincoln first uttered those memorable words in November 1863, the Gettysburg Address has been linked to our national cemeteries. In 1908, Congress approved a plan to produce a standard Gettysburg Address tablet to be installed in all national cemeteries in time for the centennial of President Lincoln’s birth on February 12, 1909.